District seeks damages for faulty tennis court construction
by Melissa Martin
Oct. 21 school board meeting
The Brecksville-Broadview Heights School Board authorized the administration to file a lawsuit against the company hired to rebuild the district tennis courts three years ago.
Superintendent Jeffrey Harrison said the district is seeking $300,000 in damages from SGC Fields LLC in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, the cost to replace the courts this past summer.
“Our tennis courts are open, have been used very much this fall and are now functioning as designed,” Harrison said.
The tennis courts, initially replaced in the 2022-2023 school year for approximately $608,000, began cracking and ponding weeks after the rebuild was complete, Harrison said, noting that SGC Fields has denied any wrongdoing in the installation and resurfacing of the courts.
Despite the district’s attempts to involve the company in determining the cause of the cracking and standing water, representatives from SGC Fields declined communication with the district last school year.
“It was difficult as a board member to approve over $600,000 to have those tennis courts rebuilt and only a year later have them have problems,” board President Mark Dosen said. “So hopefully the lawsuit gets some restitution back to the district for our cost to fix the mistakes of the contractor.”
Rob Remington, an attorney with Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP representing SGC Fields, said the company has expressed disappointment that the district is taking the matter to court. He said the company had been working in good faith with the administration to determine the cause of the problem.
“During the course of the investigation, evidence has suggested that issues with the tennis courts may have been caused by existing site conditions known to the school district and not adequately addressed by the project designs,” Remington said.
Consultants hired by the district to investigate the courts’ rapid deterioration concluded SGC Fields had insufficiently compacted the asphalt in the courts. The board’s resolution also accused the company of leaving sags in drainage pipes that restricted water flow.
“The district … discovered that SCG had failed to remove the old perimeter drains and, in certain instances, had interrupted the flow of the perimeter drains by placing fence posts into the drains or constructing the new drainage by breaking the old drainage,” the resolution states.
Harrison said the district asked SCG to correct its work or pay for another rebuild, but SCG declined.
Vasco Sports Contractors of Massillon was paid $302,199 to repair the courts in time for the first day of the 2026-2027 school year.
