Council reviews zoning changes on lighting, parking and holiday decorations

by Dan Holland

Broadview Heights City Council is reviewing zoning code changes involving lighting, parking and holiday decoration time limits, with passage targeted for the first quarter of 2027, Council President Robert Boldt said. Council discussed the revisions during Oct. 5 and Oct. 19 work sessions.

Councilmembers initially passed a resolution in January to hire McDonald Hopkins LLC to review and make recommended changes to the city’s zoning code. The same law firm is also representing the city in litigation involving Sheetz, Inc., whose plans to construct a new fueling station and convenience store in the city have been held up by a court ruling in the city’s favor (see Broadview Journal, April 2026).

According to the January agreement with McDonald Hopkins, the firm was tasked with assisting officials in providing a general overview of the city zoning code and related ordinances, advising on certain zoning provisions, updating the language, assisting with drafting zoning code amendments, attending public meetings and providing other legal assistance.

“The attorneys have come back with a 25-page document that they want to implement into the zoning,” Boldt said. “We reviewed it as council, and I said when I first came out with this, that after we had the attorneys look at it and render their opinion, then we as a city would start asking our questions and ideas to be implemented into it as well.”

“So, they gave us a list that we’re going through right now, and we’re going to give our list, which includes a few items that address areas such as lighting, parking, holiday decoration time limits and things of that nature.”

During a scheduled Dec. 2 meeting, members of the city’s planning commission and board of zoning appeals are expected to receive the recommended zoning changes for review, Boldt noted.

“They’re going to get all the changes, and we will have the BZA and Planning Commission look at it and come back to us in January, and at that point we’re going to work it out to make it legislation so it can be passed within the first quarter of next year,” Boldt explained.

Boldt noted that he and Chief Building Official Joe Mandato have kept in contact with attorneys at McDonald Hopkins regarding the zoning code review.

“It’s 27 pages of changes out of a 600-plus page document,” Boldt said. “We’ve been working through it, trying to strengthen it, so we’ll have more control and better decisions at the BZA and planning commission in consistency with the Duncan Factors [legal guidelines regarding zoning variances] to keep us out of lawsuits and keep our home rule healthy.”

Boldt also noted that he will review legal briefs tied to the litigation by Sheetz against the city, which included an additional appeal filed by Sheetz that was heard in Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas during October. A court ruling in that case had not yet been released at press time.

“In the interim, Sheetz went to final discussion on the appeal against the city,” Boldt said. “So, I asked to get all the briefs from them, so we can use that as documentation to look at if there are other items we need to put in our zoning to help make our zoning a little more robust. I’m going to find out what the attorneys are using in their arguments, so the city can use that to reduce possible litigations in the future and strengthen our zoning.”

“That’s huge for our city, because the main thing is to find out what the lawyers are fighting in court, and document that, and implement it into our zoning to eliminate future lawsuits and keep our home rule healthy,” he added. “That’s why we asked them to submit all the briefs [to us].”

During the Oct. 12 council meeting, councilmembers approved:

An agreement with Interstate Kitchen Supply for a Wolf gas range for the fire department.

An agreement with Specialized Construction Inc. for road repairs on Sprague Road.

During the Oct. 26 council meeting, councilmembers approved:

An agreement with The Baldwin Group Inc. for a parking ticket tracking system for mayor’s court.

A resolution authorizing payment of an invoice from Environmental Restoration LLC for cleanup of an oil discharge from 8770 Chaucer Blvd.

A resolution accepting the 2026 Community Recycling Awareness Grant from the Cuyahoga County Solid Waste District.