District sends 1.25-mill PI renewal levy to ballot
by Laura Bednar
July 14 regular board of education meeting, July 21 special meeting
Voters will see a permanent improvement renewal levy on the November ballot for Independence Local Schools. The 1.25-mill levy was last renewed in 2021 and expires at the end of this year. If approved, it will generate $587,996 annually and be in place for five years.
Renewal levies do not allow for adjustment due to changing property values, so taxpayers will pay no more than they did in 2021. Ohio House Bill 920 prevents a levy from collecting more than was voter-approved, even if property values rise. The levy would cost taxpayers $26 annually for every $100,000 of county-appraised property value.
The money is used for facility improvements, transportation and technology in the district. According to a press release, district officials said maintaining the PI levy is critical regardless of which long-term facilities plan is ultimately pursued, referencing the bond and income tax levy for a new school building that failed at the May polls.
Voucher lawsuit
By a 4-1 vote, the school board continued support of the Vouchers Hurt Ohio Initiative of the Ohio Coalition for Equity and Adequacy of School Funding. The lawsuit, which has the support of more than half of the state’s 611 school districts, has been ongoing since 2022.
According to the Statehouse News Bureau, the lawsuit asserts state funding of the EdChoice voucher program for students to attend private schools is unconstitutional. The lawsuit was argued in the 10th District Court of Appeals after a Franklin County Common Pleas judge found the voucher program unconstitutional. However, the judge permitted the voucher system to continue during the appeal.
“It’s not a choice when a school doesn’t have the same requirements and if the school doesn’t have to accept you,” said Superintendent Kelli Cogan, adding that public school funding by the state has decreased but voucher funding has increased. She also said the money can’t come from two different funds if it’s under the same authority.
Independence joined the suit in February 2025 with the same 4-1 vote. Board member Carrie Sears voted no, stating that the district is not getting money back that was spent on the suit. It costs the district $2,000 per year to support the lawsuit. She said she would rather use district resources elsewhere.
Sears said she agrees state dollars should not be used for private education but, “I don’t have hope that this is going to be resolved soon.”
Board Vice President Tony Avila said he wants to support the lawsuit with more than just words. But he added the proceedings have lasted long enough, so this will be the last year he votes in favor.
AP courses
Assistant Superintendent of Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Natalie Matthews said the district received the results from the high school Advanced Placement tests. There were 126 AP tests taken this year with a passage rate of 78%. A passing grade is a 3 on a 1-5 scale, with 5 being the best.
Last year the passage rate was 89%. Matthews said there were 20 fewer students taking tests this year and the average score dropped from 3.7 to 3.4.
Technology costs
The board approved two contracts with Quadstar totaling $130,000 to support the district’s computers and networks with an engineer on site daily and an engineer available specifically to maintain the network. Cogan said the district is conducting a technology audit in August and will make recommendations on potential changes.
